APMEX vs SD Bullion

How These Dealers Compare

APMEX and SD Bullion represent two fundamentally different approaches to selling precious metals online. APMEX, founded in 2000, built its business on being the everything store for precious metals. Over 10,000 products, from fractional gold to vintage numismatics, fill a catalog that no competitor matches in breadth. SD Bullion, launched in 2012, took the opposite path: a lean product catalog with the lowest premiums it can sustain.

The decision between these two dealers comes down to a simple question. Do you want the widest selection and a mature buying platform, or do you want to pay the least possible per ounce on common bullion? Rarely does a single dealer win on both counts. Read our full APMEX review and SD Bullion review for in-depth assessments of each.

Pricing: Where SD Bullion Pulls Ahead

Premium differences between APMEX and SD Bullion are significant and consistent. On a 1 oz American Gold Eagle (check/wire pricing), APMEX typically charges $40-75 over spot while SD Bullion sits at $25-45 over spot. That is a $15-30 difference per coin, and it adds up fast on multi-coin orders.

Silver premiums tell a similar story. Generic 1 oz silver rounds at APMEX price at $2.00-4.00 over spot, while SD Bullion offers the same products at $1.00-2.50 over spot. On a 100 oz silver bar, SD Bullion's premiums are often $0.50-1.50 per ounce over spot, some of the lowest from any reputable dealer. For a buyer purchasing 100 oz of silver, the premium savings at SD Bullion versus APMEX can total $50-150 on a single order.

On a monster box of 500 American Silver Eagles, the premium gap between APMEX and SD Bullion can exceed $500. That is not a rounding error. It is enough to buy an additional 15+ ounces of silver at current prices.

SD Bullion also offers a price match guarantee. If a competitor lists an identical in-stock product at a lower price, SD Bullion will match it. APMEX does not offer a formal price match policy.

Track live premium data across both dealers on our premium tracker.

Product Selection: Where APMEX Dominates

No online dealer matches APMEX on selection. Over 10,000 products span gold, silver, platinum, palladium, and copper. Rare and collectible coins, certified numismatics, vintage US gold coins, limited-edition mint releases, and fractional gold in every weight from 1/10 oz to 1 oz fill a catalog designed for both investors and collectors.

SD Bullion's catalog is deliberately narrow. Core bullion products are well-represented: gold bars and coins from major refiners, silver bars (1 oz to 100 oz), rounds, sovereign coins, and some platinum. But limited numismatic inventory, few vintage items, and minimal fractional gold options mean that specialized buyers will often need to shop elsewhere.

For the buyer who wants a 1/10 oz gold coin from a specific mint year, an obscure international sovereign, or a certified pre-1933 gold piece, APMEX is the only realistic option between these two. For the buyer who wants 10 oz of generic silver rounds at the lowest price, SD Bullion is the better call.

Website and Ordering Experience

APMEX's website reflects 25 years of continuous refinement. Filtering by metal type, product category, weight, mint, and price range works reliably. The ability to sort by premium-over-spot is particularly useful for surfacing the best relative value within a category. Search handles both broad queries and specific product lookups. The mobile app adds real-time price alerts and push notifications for price dips.

SD Bullion's website functions adequately but lacks polish. Navigation is workable, product filtering has improved over time, and payment-tiered pricing displays clearly. However, inconsistent product photography, less intuitive search, and a dated visual design create friction, especially for newer buyers who want confidence that they are ordering the right product. Experienced stackers who know exactly what they want will navigate SD Bullion without issues.

Shipping and Delivery

Both dealers offer free shipping on orders over $199 with full insurance via USPS, UPS, or FedEx. In-stock items typically ship within 1-3 business days for card payments at both retailers.

APMEX ships from Oklahoma City, providing central US transit times. SD Bullion ships from Michigan, which offers fast delivery to the eastern half of the country and standard ground timelines to the West Coast.

Packaging is discreet and secure at both dealers, with unmarked boxes and appropriate protective materials. Neither dealer regularly generates complaints about damaged shipments.

Customer Service and Buyback

APMEX offers phone, email, and live chat support with extended hours. The support infrastructure handles high-volume periods well, reflecting the company's scale. Customer service reviews are generally positive, with responsive and knowledgeable staff.

SD Bullion provides phone and email support. Customer service reviews are more mixed than APMEX's, with some buyers reporting slower response times. For straightforward orders that do not require support interaction, this gap is irrelevant. For complex issues, returns, or buyback transactions, the difference in service quality may matter.

Both dealers operate buyback programs. You can lock in a sell price online or by phone at either dealer. Buyback spreads are competitive at both, though exact pricing depends on the product and market conditions.

The Bottom Line

Choose SD Bullion if you prioritize paying the lowest possible premium on common bullion products. SD Bullion consistently undercuts APMEX by $15-30 per ounce on gold and $0.50-1.50 per ounce on silver. The price match guarantee adds confidence. If cost-per-ounce is your primary metric, SD Bullion is the stronger choice.

Choose APMEX if you want the widest product selection, a polished website, or access to rare and collectible coins. APMEX's catalog depth is unmatched, and the buying experience is more refined. For collectors, IRA investors, and buyers who value convenience over squeezing every basis point, APMEX justifies the premium difference.

Both dealers are legitimate and well-established with BBB A+ ratings. For more dealer pricing data, check our live premium tracker. Browse all dealer reviews for the full picture.

Frequently Asked Questions